top of page

Petersen v. Argentina: New Investment Treaty Arbitration Following US Court Ruling

Writer: Aişe Gül Akkoyun
Aişe Gül Akkoyun
Sep 28
1 min read

What changes when shareholders pursue investment treaty arbitration after a setback in US litigation over the same investment?

Background

On 15 September 2026, ICSID registered Petersen Energía S.A.U. and Petersen Energía Inversora S.A.U. v. Argentine Republic (ARB/26/38), a new arbitration under the 1991 Spain–Argentina bilateral investment treaty.

The dispute concerns Argentina’s acquisition of control over an Argentine oil and gas company in 2012. The Petersen companies were shareholders in that company. They brought claims in the United States alleging that Argentina had failed to make the offer to purchase other shareholders’ shares required by the company’s bylaws. On 27 March 2026, the US Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit reversed the judgment against Argentina, holding that the contractual damages claims were not cognizable under Argentine law.

Treaty claims after a contractual loss

The new arbitration raises a question worth following: how will the claimants distinguish their treaty claims from the shareholder rights examined in the US proceedings? The US court addressed contractual claims; it did not determine Argentina’s liability under the investment treaty.

Where Argentine law comes back in

Argentine law may nevertheless remain relevant. Article X(5) of the treaty includes host-State law among the applicable sources of law, alongside the treaty and general principles of international law. Article X(2)–(3) also provides for recourse to host-State courts and sets out the conditions for proceeding to international arbitration.

What to watch

The public ICSID record does not yet disclose the detailed claims or how the claimants address these provisions. As further materials become available, the interaction between treaty protection, domestic shareholder rights and the earlier US judgment will be worth following.

Comments


bottom of page