top of page

Can an ICSID Award Be Sold Without the State's Consent? Operafund v. Spain

Writer: Aişe Gül Akkoyun
Aişe Gül Akkoyun
2 days ago
2 min read

Imagine you have won an arbitration against a State, but the State refuses to pay. Enforcement could take years, and you would rather have the money now. One option is to sell the award to a specialised buyer. The buyer pays less than the award is worth, because it takes on the risk and the wait, and then chases the State itself. Over the past decade, this has become a small market of its own.

A recent English judgment makes that option much harder.

Background

On 2 November 2026, the Court of Appeal decided Operafund Eco-Invest SICAV plc and others v Kingdom of Spain [2026] EWCA Civ 1392. The facts are simple. Two investors won a €29.3 million award against Spain in 2019. The case was brought under the Energy Charter Treaty after Spain cut its support for renewable energy. The award was rendered under the ICSID Convention, the World Bank treaty that governs most investor-State arbitrations and requires member States to enforce its awards like final judgments of their own courts. In 2024, the investors sold their rights under the award to a US company, Blasket Renewable Investments. To collect, Blasket first needed the award registered in England, which turns it into something an English court can enforce, and then needed to be recognised as the person entitled to the money. It asked the court to let it take the investors’ place.

The Court’s answer

The Court said no. In its view, international law does not allow an ICSID award to be transferred without the consent of the State that owes it. This may sound technical, but it matters to the State: it agreed to arbitrate with a particular investor, and it may not want to face a professional buyer whose whole business is collecting debts from governments. The Convention lets “a party” to the award seek enforcement, and a buyer is not a party. Registering the award in England did not change that.

Other courts see it differently

What makes this interesting is that other courts see it differently. In 2025, the Federal Court of Australia accepted the same buyer’s rights under similar awards against Spain. The English Court openly acknowledged that it was taking a different path from lower courts in Australia, the United States and the Netherlands. In practice, the same kind of award can now be sold in one country but not in another.

Which consent matters

Last month, I wrote about Singapore, where Spain’s consent to Article 54 of the ICSID Convention helped investors defeat its immunity defence. This case shows the other side of that coin: the State’s consent also decides who can collect. Taken together, the two decisions suggest that at the enforcement stage, the question is no longer only whether a State agreed to arbitrate, but whom it agreed to pay.

Comments


bottom of page